16-Civ-B6 Urban and Regional Planning, May 2018: worked solutions

Paper format. 16-Civ-B6 Urban and Regional Planning, National Examinations, May 2018. Three hours, closed book, calculator permitted but no calculation is set. Part A: Questions 1 and 2, both compulsory, 25 marks each, three sub-parts each. Part B: Questions 3–10 at 10 marks each, of which five are to be answered. A complete paper is therefore 100 marks. Note 6 on the front page states that most questions require an essay answer and that “Clarify [sic] and organization of the answer are important” (the printed paper reads “Clarify” where “clarity” is plainly intended) — structure and argument are marked here, not arithmetic.

Check — scope and assumptions. The Part B header prints “ANSWER FIVE (5) OF THE FOLLOWING SEVEN (7) QUESTIONS” but eight questions (3–10) are actually printed on pages 3 and 4. Front-page Note 4 governs and is the consistent reading: the first two questions plus any five of the remainder. All ten questions are answered in full below because this document is a study resource rather than a submitted script; Question 6 likewise defines all eight listed terms rather than the five asked, and Question 7 discusses all six listed subjects rather than two. Questions 1 and 2 give a scenario but no engineering data, so where a quantity is used to make an argument concrete it is introduced as an explicitly stated assumption — permitted, and indeed invited, by front-page Note 1. The paper uses Ontario’s vocabulary (“Official Plan”, “minor variance”, “site plan control”), so Ontario’s Planning Act is cited as the primary statute with the British Columbia Local Government Act equivalent given alongside; the answers stay in the Canadian frame throughout.

Reference texts for 16-Civ-B6.

Hodge, G., Gordon, D.L.A. & Shaw, P., Planning Canadian Communities: An Introduction to the Principles, Practice and Participants, 7th ed., Nelson Education — the core Canadian text for this examination code.
Levy, J.M., Contemporary Urban Planning, 11th ed., Routledge — planning history, theory, tools, and the North American regulatory framework.
Hodge, G. & Robinson, I.M., Planning Canadian Regions, UBC Press — regional planning, growth management and metropolitan governance.
Grant, J.L. (ed.), A Reader in Canadian Planning: Linking Theory and Practice, Nelson — Canadian case material on participation, suburbs and sustainability.
Provincial statutes: Ontario Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13 (ss. 17, 24, 34, 41, 45, 51); British Columbia Local Government Act, R.S.B.C. 2015, c. 1 (Parts 14–15) and Land Title Act Part 7; federal Impact Assessment Act, S.C. 2019, c. 28.
Transportation Association of Canada, Canadian Guide to Neighbourhood Traffic Calming; International Association for Public Participation (IAP2), Spectrum of Public Participation.

16-Civ-B6 Urban and Regional Planning: May 2018