16-Civ-A1 Elementary Structural Analysis · May 2017
Question 2 of 8: Reactions, shear and bending-moment diagrams
Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)
Notes on this paper
Paper: National Exams — May 2017, 16-Civ-A1 Elementary Structural Analysis (closed book, 3 h). Six questions constitute a complete paper: answer Q1–Q5 and one of Q6/Q7/Q8. For completeness all eight questions are worked here.
Sign convention: upward reactions positive; sagging bending moment positive (tension on the underside); member tension positive (T), compression negative (C).
These A1 papers are defined entirely by their figures, so every structure has been read from the printed figure and redrawn to scale below.
Question 2: Reactions, shear and bending-moment diagrams (18 marks)
Given. Pin at $A$ ($x{=}0$), roller at $B$ ($x{=}6\text{ m}$), overhang to $x{=}8\text{ m}$; UDL $12\text{ kN/m}$ over $A$–$B$; point load $30\text{ kN}$ at the free tip. Find. Reactions and SFD/BMD extremes.
2(a): 12 kN/m over the 6 m span, 30 kN at the overhang tip.
Reactions. $\sum M_A=0:\;R_B(6)=12(6)(3)+30(8)=216+240=456\Rightarrow R_B=\boxed{76\text{ kN}}$; then $R_A=12(6)+30-76=\boxed{26\text{ kN}}$.
Shear. $V=+26$ at $A$, falling with the UDL to $26-12(6)=-46$ just left of $B$; the reaction lifts it to $-46+76=+30$, constant across the overhang, and the $30\text{ kN}$ tip load returns it to $0$. Extremes $V_{\max}=\boxed{+30\text{ kN}}$, $V_{\min}=\boxed{-46\text{ kN}}$.
Moment. $V=0$ at $x=26/12=2.17\text{ m}$, giving peak sagging $M=26(2.17)-6(2.17)^2=\boxed{+28.2\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$. Over the roller $M(6)=26(6)-12(6)(3)=-60\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}$ (check from the overhang: $-30(2)=-60$), the peak hogging $\boxed{-60\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$, returning to $0$ at the tip.
2(a) SFD.
2(a) BMD (sagging +).
2(b) L-frame with internal hinge
Given. Column fixed at base, height $3\text{ m}$, horizontal UDL $4\text{ kN/m}$; rigid corner into a horizontal beam carrying $8\text{ kN/m}$ down; internal hinge $1.5\text{ m}$ from the corner; roller $6\text{ m}$ beyond the hinge (i.e. $7.5\text{ m}$ from the corner). Find. Reactions and SFD/BMD. The hinge makes the frame determinate ($r=4$, $c=1$).
Hinge release fixes the roller. Taking moments about the hinge for the beam to its right (length $6\text{ m}$, UDL $8$): $R_C(6)=8(6)(3)\Rightarrow R_C=\boxed{24\text{ kN}}$.
Base reactions. $\sum F_y:\;V_A=8(7.5)-24=\boxed{36\text{ kN}}$; $\sum F_x:\;H_A=4(3)=\boxed{12\text{ kN}}$ (leftward, resisting the wind); $\sum M_A:\;M_A=8(7.5)(3.75)-24(7.5)+4(3)(1.5)=\boxed{63\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$.
Beam BMD. With corner moment and $M=0$ at the hinge, $M(x)=-45+36x-4x^2$ (x from corner). Corner (hogging) $\boxed{-45\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$; $V=0$ at $x=4.5\text{ m}$ giving peak sag $M=-45+36(4.5)-4(4.5)^2=\boxed{+36\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$; zero at hinge and roller. Beam shear runs $+36$ (corner) to $-24$ (roller).
Column BMD. Parabolic under the $4\text{ kN/m}$: base $\boxed{+63\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$ (max), corner $-45\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}$; column shear $12\to 0$.
2(c) Gable (bent simply-supported member)
Given. Pin at $A(0,0)$, roller at $B(12.5,0)$, apex $(8,6)$. Two loads perpendicular to the left rafter (length $10\text{ m}$): $15\text{ kN}$ at $3\text{ m}$ and $16\text{ kN}$ at $5\text{ m}$ from $A$. Find. Reactions and BMD/SFD. Each perpendicular load resolves as $(0.6,-0.8)\times P$.
2(c): gable with two loads normal to the rising rafter.
Moments (from the load-free side). At the apex, only $B_y$ acts to the right: $M_{apex}=10(12.5-8)=\boxed{45\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$. At the $16\text{ kN}$ point ($5\text{ m}$): $M=10(12.5-4.0)=\boxed{85\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$ (the peak). At the $15\text{ kN}$ point ($3\text{ m}$): $M=69\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}$; zero at both supports. All sagging (tension on the inner face).
Shear (normal to axis). Left rafter: $+23\text{ kN}$ ($A$ to $3\text{ m}$), $+8$ ($3$–$5\text{ m}$), $-8$ ($5\text{ m}$–apex); right rafter constant $+6\text{ kN}$.
2(c) BMD read along the rafters from A (0) to apex (10 m).