Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)
Notes on this paper
National Exams — May 2019 — 11-CS-2 Engineering in Society: Health and Safety. Closed book. Do any five of the seven questions (each 10 marks); a bonus question (5 marks) may be attempted in addition. Full essay-type answers are expected. Complete answers to all seven questions and the bonus follow.
Class A — ordinary combustible solids: wood, paper, cloth, rubber, many plastics.
Class B — flammable liquids and gases: gasoline, oil, solvents, paint, propane.
Class C — fires in or near energized electrical equipment.
Class D — combustible metals: magnesium, sodium, potassium, titanium.
(Some systems add Class K/F for cooking oils and fats; the question specifies four classes.)
(b) Suitable and Prohibited Agents (with reasons)
Class A — use water (cooling), foam, or ABC dry chemical. Water is effective and cheap because it removes heat.
Class B — use foam, CO₂, or dry chemical (smother/interrupt reaction). Do not use a water jet: it spreads the burning liquid and can cause flare-up.
Class C — use CO₂ or dry chemical (non-conductive). Do not use water or foam: they conduct electricity, risking electrocution of the operator and equipment damage. (De-energize, then it becomes a Class A/B fire.)
Class D — use special dry-powder agents designed for the specific metal. Do not use water: burning metals react violently with water (releasing hydrogen/explosion); CO₂ and standard agents are also ineffective or dangerous.
(c) Suppression Agents and How They Work
Fire needs fuel, oxygen, heat and a sustaining chain reaction (the fire tetrahedron); each agent removes one or more legs:
Water — cooling: absorbs heat, dropping the fuel below its ignition temperature.
Foam — smothering + cooling: forms a blanket over a liquid surface, excluding oxygen and suppressing vapour.
Carbon dioxide — smothering: displaces oxygen (and provides some cooling); leaves no residue, good for electrical/electronics.
Dry chemical powders — chemically interrupt the chain reaction of combustion.
Clean (gaseous) agents — inert gases or halocarbons that smother or interrupt the reaction without residue.
Wet chemical — for cooking oils: saponifies the oil to form a cooling, smothering layer.