Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)
Notes on this paper
Paper format. 16-Mec-B6 Fluid Machinery,
National Examinations May 2017 — three hours, closed book. Section A is
calculative (Questions 1–5) and Section B descriptive (Questions 6–8); the rubric asks for
four of Section A and two of Section B, six questions of ten marks each for a sixty-mark paper.
Reference data for individual questions are supplied as Attachments (pages 9–11) and a general
constants/equations sheet occupies pages 12–16. All eight questions are solved
here, because the set is a study resource rather than a timed attempt.
Reference texts.
S. L. Dixon & C. A. Hall, Fluid Mechanics and Thermodynamics of Turbomachinery, 7th ed.;
R. K. Turton, Principles of Turbomachinery, 2nd ed.;
H. Cohen, G. F. C. Rogers & H. I. H. Saravanamuttoo, Gas Turbine Theory, 6th ed.;
F. M. White, Fluid Mechanics, 8th ed.;
R. W. Fox, A. T. McDonald & P. J. Pritchard, Introduction to Fluid Mechanics, 9th ed.;
Y. A. Çengel & M. A. Boles, Thermodynamics: An Engineering Approach, 9th ed.
Constants are those printed on page 13 of the paper
(g = 9.81 m/s², ρwater = 1000 kg/m³,
ρair = 1.21 kg/m³ at 15 °C and 1.19 kg/m³
at 20 °C, cp = 1.005 kJ/kg·°C,
cv = 0.718 kJ/kg·°C, patm = 100 kPa,
pvapour = 2.34 kPa).
Subject note. Page 1 of the examination reads
16-MEC-B6 FLUID MACHINERY, and every question is a turbomachine question. The
solutions below answer the paper as printed.
Given. A simple open-cycle, single-shaft gas turbine:
Quantity
Symbol
Value
Compressor pressure ratio
rp
12.0
Ambient (compressor inlet) pressure
p1
100 kPa
Ambient (compressor inlet) temperature
T1
15 °C = 288.15 K
Turbine inlet temperature
T3
1077 °C = 1350.15 K
Compressor isentropic efficiency
ηc
0.86
Turbine isentropic efficiency
ηt
0.89
Mechanical (shaft) efficiency
ηm
0.98
Air/fuel ratio by mass
A/F
50
Working fluid properties (page 13)
cp, cv
1.005, 0.718 kJ/kg·K ⇒ k = 1.4
Find. The T-s diagram with every state numbered, the temperature at each numbered
state, the net specific work in kW·s per kilogram of gas leaving the turbine, and the specific
fuel consumption in kilograms of fuel per kilowatt-hour.
Figure 1.1 — T-s diagram of the simple single-shaft cycle. 1 ambient, 2s ideal compressor delivery, 2 actual compressor delivery, 3 turbine inlet, 4s ideal turbine exhaust, 4 actual turbine exhaust. Part (a) of the question.
Approach. Fix the two isentropic end states from the pressure ratio, open
them out to the real end states with the two component efficiencies, then take a work balance
per kilogram of gas passing through the turbine — the compressor handles only the air
part of that gas, which is where the air/fuel ratio enters.
Part (a) — number the cycle and identify each process. State 1 is ambient
air at the compressor intake; 1→2 is the real (irreversible) compression against the delivery
pressure $p_2 = r_p p_1 = 1200\ \text{kPa}$, with 2s the ideal end point on
the same pressure line; 2→3 is constant-pressure combustion to the turbine inlet temperature;
3→4 is the real expansion back to 100 kPa, with 4s its ideal counterpart; and 4→1 closes
the diagram as the atmospheric rejection of the exhaust. Figure 1.1 is the required sketch. Both
irreversible processes lean to the right, because entropy is generated in each.
Part (b) — ideal compressor delivery temperature. Along an isentrope
between the two pressure levels,
$$\frac{T_{2s}}{T_1}=\left(\frac{p_2}{p_1}\right)^{(k-1)/k}=12^{0.2857}=2.034$$
so $T_{2s}=288.15\times 2.034$, giving
$$\boxed{T_{2s}=586.1\ \text{K}\ (313.0\ ^\circ\text{C})}$$
Real compressor delivery. The isentropic efficiency is the ratio of ideal to
actual temperature rise, so the real rise is the larger of the two:
$$T_2=T_1+\frac{T_{2s}-T_1}{\eta_c}=288.15+\frac{297.9}{0.86}=634.6\ \text{K}$$
$$\boxed{T_2=634.6\ \text{K}\ (361.4\ ^\circ\text{C})}$$
Ideal turbine exhaust temperature. The expansion returns to ambient pressure
through the same ratio, so
$$T_{4s}=\frac{T_3}{12^{0.2857}}=\frac{1350.15}{2.034}=663.8\ \text{K}$$
Real turbine exhaust. Here the efficiency multiplies the ideal drop, because the
real machine delivers less than the isentropic work:
$$T_4=T_3-\eta_t\,(T_3-T_{4s})=1350.15-0.89\times 686.4=739.3\ \text{K}$$
$$\boxed{T_4=739.3\ \text{K}\ (466.2\ ^\circ\text{C})}$$
State 3 is given directly as $T_3=1350.15$ K and state 1 as
$T_1=288.15$ K, which completes part (b).
Part (c) — split the mass flow between air and gas. The question asks for
work per kilogram of gas, and the gas leaving the combustor is air plus fuel. With
$A/F=50$, one kilogram of gas contains
$$m_{air}=\frac{50}{51}=0.9804\ \text{kg air},\qquad m_{fuel}=\frac{1}{51}=0.01961\ \text{kg fuel}$$
The turbine passes the whole kilogram; the compressor only ever handled the air fraction.
Turbine and compressor specific works. Treating the products as air with the
page-13 specific heat,
$$w_t=c_p\,(T_3-T_4)=1.005\times 610.9=613.9\ \text{kJ/kg of gas}$$
$$w_c=\frac{A/F}{A/F+1}\,c_p\,(T_2-T_1)=0.9804\times 1.005\times 346.4=341.3\ \text{kJ/kg of gas}$$
Net specific work output. The shaft efficiency debits the mechanical losses
between turbine and compressor:
$$w_{net}=\eta_m w_t-w_c=0.98\times 613.9-341.3=260.3\ \text{kJ/kg}$$
Because one kilojoule per kilogram is one kilowatt-second per kilogram,
$$\boxed{w_{net}=260.3\ \text{kW}\cdot\text{s/kg of gas}}$$
Part (d) — specific fuel consumption. Each kilogram of gas carries
0.01961 kg of fuel and yields 260.3 kJ of shaft work; one kilowatt-hour is 3600 kJ, so
$$\text{SFC}=\frac{m_{fuel}}{w_{net}}\times 3600=\frac{0.01961}{260.3}\times 3600$$
$$\boxed{\text{SFC}=0.271\ \text{kg/kWh}}$$
Check the answer against the cycle efficiency. The heat added is
$q_{in}=c_p(T_3-T_2)=1.005\times 715.6=719.2$ kJ/kg, so the thermal
efficiency is $260.3/719.2=36.2\ \%$. A fuel of calorific value about
45 MJ/kg burnt at an air/fuel ratio of 50 releases roughly
$45000/51=882$ kJ per kilogram of gas, and 36 % of that is close to the
computed net work — the two routes agree, which confirms the mass bookkeeping.
Quantity
Symbol
Result
Compressor inlet (state 1)
T1
288.2 K (15.0 °C)
Ideal compressor delivery (state 2s)
T2s
586.1 K (313.0 °C)
Actual compressor delivery (state 2)
T2
634.6 K (361.4 °C)
Turbine inlet (state 3)
T3
1350.2 K (1077.0 °C)
Ideal turbine exhaust (state 4s)
T4s
663.8 K (390.7 °C)
Actual turbine exhaust (state 4)
T4
739.3 K (466.2 °C)
Turbine specific work
wt
613.9 kJ/kg gas
Compressor specific work
wc
341.3 kJ/kg gas
Net specific work output
wnet
260.3 kW·s/kg gas
Specific fuel consumption
SFC
0.271 kg/kWh
Cycle thermal efficiency (check)
ηth
36.2 %
Check: shaft-efficiency convention. The mechanical efficiency
has been applied once, to the turbine output, so that
$w_{net}=\eta_m w_t-w_c$. Some texts instead charge the loss to the
compressor drive, $w_{net}=w_t-w_c/\eta_m$, which would give 265.3 kJ/kg and
an SFC of 0.266 kg/kWh — a 2 % difference. State whichever convention you use; the marker is
looking for the audit trail, not a particular one of the two.