Question 10 of 10: Radiation Resistance, Efficiency and Field Intensity of a Steel Wire Antenna
Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)
Notes on this paper
17-Phys-A3, Electromagnetics — National Exam, May 2019. 3-hour closed-book exam (Casio or Sharp approved calculators only, one 8.5″×11″ aid sheet); any FIVE of the printed questions constitute a complete exam paper and only the first five as they appear in a candidate's answer book are marked, each of equal value, with full justification required for marks. All ten printed questions are solved below as a complete study resource.
Reference texts: Sadiku, Elements of Electromagnetics (7th ed.) — plane waves and boundaries, Gauss's law, resistance and current density, magnetostatics; Hayt & Buck, Engineering Electromagnetics (9th ed.) — transmission-line transients and bounce diagrams; Pozar, Microwave Engineering (4th ed.) — transmission-line theory, rectangular waveguide cutoff; Balanis, Antenna Theory: Analysis and Design (4th ed.) — short-dipole radiation resistance and efficiency.
Question 10: Radiation Resistance, Efficiency and Field Intensity of a Steel Wire Antenna (20 marks)
Find. $R_r$; the radiation efficiency $\xi$; $|E|$ at $r=20$ km.
Approach. $\lambda=c/f=300$ m gives $l/\lambda=0.05\ll1$, so this is an electrically-short antenna; "uniform current" means the idealized (Hertzian) short-dipole radiation-resistance formula applies directly (not the triangular-current form used for an open-circuited linear dipole). The loss resistance comes from skin-effect surface resistance of the steel wire; efficiency is $R_r/(R_r+R_{loss})$. The field at a distance uses the short dipole's directivity $D=1.5$ with the GIVEN radiated power (independent of parts 1–2).
Part (a)/1 — Radiation resistance. $\lambda=c/f=(3\times10^8)/(10^6)=300$ m, $l/\lambda=15/300=0.0500$:
$$R_r=80\pi^2\left(\frac{l}{\lambda}\right)^2=80\pi^2(0.0500)^2=\boxed{1.98\ \Omega.}$$
Part (b)/2 — Loss resistance (skin effect) and efficiency. Surface resistance of the steel wire:
$$R_s=\sqrt{\frac{\pi f\mu_0}{\sigma}}=\sqrt{\frac{\pi(10^6)(4\pi\times10^{-7})}{6.2\times10^6}}=7.98\times10^{-4}\ \Omega/\text{sq}.$$
The high-frequency (skin-effect) loss resistance of a round wire of length $l$, radius $b$ is $R_{loss}=R_sl/(2\pi b)$:
$$R_{loss}=\frac{(7.98\times10^{-4})(15)}{2\pi(0.02)}=\boxed{0.0953\ \Omega.}$$
$$\xi=\frac{R_r}{R_r+R_{loss}}=\frac{1.98}{1.98+0.0953}=\boxed{95.4\%.}$$
Part (c)/3 — Field intensity at 20 km for 1 kW radiated. A short dipole has directivity $D=1.5$ in its maximum (broadside) direction, so the maximum time-average power density at distance $r$ is
$$S_{max}=\frac{DP_{rad}}{4\pi r^2}=\frac{(1.5)(1000)}{4\pi(20000)^2}=2.984\times10^{-7}\ \text{W/m}^2.$$
Relating this to the peak field via $S_{avg}=|E_{max}|^2/(2\eta_0)$:
$$|E_{max}|=\sqrt{2\eta_0S_{max}}=\sqrt{2(376.7)(2.984\times10^{-7})}=\boxed{0.01499\ \text{V/m}=15.0\ \text{mV/m}.}$$
Final results
Quantity
Value
Radiation resistance, $R_r$
1.98 Ω
Loss resistance, $R_{loss}$
0.0953 Ω
Radiation efficiency, $\xi$
95.4%
Field intensity at 20 km (1 kW radiated)
15.0 mV/m
Check: treated as a free-space short dipole with uniform current (per the problem's own wording), not a grounded monopole with an image plane — no ground/earth return is mentioned in the problem, so no image-theory factor of 2 is applied.