Question 2 of 6: Question 2 (paper Question II) — Plane Truss Member Forces (Part A · Statics, equal value)
Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)
Notes on this paper
National Examination 04-BS-3, Statics and Dynamics — 2018-Dec. Candidates were required to complete 2 questions from PART A (Statics) and 2 questions from PART B (Dynamics); every question is solved below so this paper serves as a complete study resource (Questions 1-3 = paper Part A, I-III; Questions 4-6 = paper Part B, IV-VI).
Check — source reconstruction notes. (2) Question 1's figure gives explicit coordinates for D, E, F and an explicit height (3 m) for wall anchor C, but not a separate height for wall anchor B; reading the drawing against its own calibrated vertical scale (using the printed "3 m" and "1 m" dimensions as reference) places B at very nearly the same height as C, and only that reading makes the six equilibrium equations for the 5-unknown system (3 reactions at A + 2 cable tensions) consistent AND returns exact, textbook-clean numbers (cable lengths of exactly 3 m each, tensions of exactly 4200 N each) — strong corroborating evidence for the reconstruction. B = (0, -2, 3) m and C = (0, 2, 3) m (both relative to A) are used below. (3) Question 3's figure dimensions the horizontal offset of the top pivots E, F (275 mm) and the vertical drop from E/F to C/D and from C/D to A/B (500 mm each), but not a horizontal offset for C, D; the crate's own 300 mm grip width fixes A, B at ±150 mm, so the jaw arm C-A is read as tapering inward from x = -275 mm (at C, in line with E) to x = -150 mm (at A) over its 500 mm drop — the taper is placed on the lower arm segment (C to A) rather than the upper one (E to C), consistent with the visible bend in the source drawing.
Question 2 (paper Question II) — Plane Truss Member Forces (Part A · Statics, equal value)
Given. Joint coordinates (m, each grid division = 1 m): A(0,0), B(4,2), C(0,4), D(4,6), E(9,6). Members: A–C, A–B, A–D, C–D, B–D, B–E, D–E. Pin support at A; roller at C bearing against the vertical wall (horizontal reaction only). Applied at E: 1.5 kN down and 2 kN right.
Given data
Item
Value
Joints (m)
A(0,0) B(4,2) C(0,4) D(4,6) E(9,6)
Members (7)
AC, AB, AD, CD, BD, BE, DE
Supports
Pin at A (2 reactions); roller at C on the vertical wall (1 horizontal reaction)
Applied load at E
1.5 kN down, 2 kN right
Find. The force (tension or compression) in every member.
Figure 2. Truss with pin support at A, roller (horizontal reaction) at C; 1.5 kN down + 2 kN right applied at E.
Approach. Confirm static determinacy, find the three support reactions from global equilibrium, then solve member forces joint-by-joint starting at the joints with only two unknown members.
Determinacy check. $m+r=7+3=10=2j=2(5)$ — the truss is statically determinate.
Support reactions. Summing moments about A (roller reaction $C_x$ is horizontal, acting at $(0,4)$): $\sum M_A=0$: $-4C_x+[9(-1500)-6(2000)]=0\Rightarrow \boxed{C_x=-6375\ \text{N}}$ (6375 N pointing into the wall, $-x$). $\sum F_x=0$: $A_x+C_x+2000=0\Rightarrow \boxed{A_x=4375\ \text{N}}$. $\sum F_y=0$: $A_y-1500=0\Rightarrow \boxed{A_y=1500\ \text{N}}$.
Joint E (members BE, DE only). $\overrightarrow{EB}=(-5,-4)$, $|EB|=\sqrt{41}=6.403$; $\overrightarrow{ED}=(-5,0)$, $|ED|=5$. $\sum F_y=0$: $F_{BE}(-4/6.403)-1500=0\Rightarrow \boxed{F_{BE}=-2401\ \text{N (2401 N C)}}$. $\sum F_x=0$: $F_{BE}(-5/6.403)+F_{DE}(-1)+2000=0\Rightarrow \boxed{F_{DE}=3875\ \text{N (T)}}$.
Joint B (members AB, BD, BE — $F_{BE}$ already known). $\overrightarrow{BA}=(-4,-2)$, $|BA|=\sqrt{20}=4.472$; $\overrightarrow{BD}=(0,4)$; $\overrightarrow{BE}=(5,4)$, $|BE|=6.403$. $\sum F_y=0$: $F_{AB}(-2/4.472)+F_{BD}+F_{BE}(4/6.403)=0$. $\sum F_x=0$: $F_{AB}(-4/4.472)+F_{BE}(5/6.403)=0\Rightarrow \boxed{F_{AB}=-2096\ \text{N (2096 N C)}}$; substituting, $\boxed{F_{BD}=563\ \text{N (T)}}$.
Joint A (check). With $F_{AC}$, $F_{AB}$ known, equilibrium at A gives $\boxed{F_{AD}=-4507\ \text{N (4507 N C)}}$, and back-substituting into $\sum F_x, \sum F_y$ at A reproduces $A_x=4375$ N and $A_y=1500$ N exactly, confirming the solution.
Final results (T = tension, C = compression)
Member
Force
AC
3188 N (T)
AB
2096 N (C)
AD
4507 N (C)
CD
7127 N (T)
BD
563 N (T)
BE
2401 N (C)
DE
3875 N (T)
Reactions
$A_x=4375$ N, $A_y=1500$ N, $C_x=6375$ N (into wall)