NivaarExam PrepOfficial exam papers ↗

24-Bld-A2 Elementary Structural Design · December 2017

Question 4 of 7: T-beam design for an overhanging concrete beam

Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)

Notes on this paper

National Examinations December 2017 — 07-Bld-A2 Elementary Structural Design, 3 hours, closed book (handbooks/textbooks permitted). Answer five: two of Questions A1–A3, two of B1–B3, and the one question C1 (this solution set, per pipeline convention, answers all seven). All loads shown in the exam are unfactored.

Reference texts: CSA S16:19, Design of Steel Structures; Salmon & Johnson, Steel Structures: Design and Behavior; CSA A23.3:19, Design of Concrete Structures; MacGregor & Bartlett, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design; CSA O86:19, Engineering Design in Wood; Canadian Wood Council, Wood Design Manual.

Check – assumptions applied throughout this solution set (the exam gives unfactored loads without separating dead/live, per Note 6, and instructs "assume any other data required"):

  • All specified (unfactored) loads are factored by a single combined load factor of 1.5 for ULS design, consistent with treating an undifferentiated load as governed by the live-load-dominant NBCC combination.
  • Material grades: structural steel plate/tie/beam – G40.21 350W (Fy=350 MPa); concrete f’c=35 MPa, reinforcement fy=400 MPa (as given for B1–B3); glulam – Douglas Fir-Larch 20f-E (fb=25.6 MPa, fc=30.2 MPa, E=12400 MPa, E05=9500 MPa, per CSA O86/Wood Design Manual).
  • Concrete cover/bar placement (exact stirrup and layer detail not dimensioned on the exam figures) is assumed at a standard 40–50 mm clear cover, giving effective depths stated with each question.

Question B1: T-beam design for an overhanging concrete beam (8 + 8 + 4 marks)

Question text not reproduced: the examination questions are © Engineers and Geoscientists BC. Open the official past paper (linked at the top of this page) to read the question, then follow the worked solution below.

Given. Overhang AB=1 m, main span BC=6 m (roller at B, pin at C); 100 kN at the free tip A; 300 kN at midspan of BC; f’c=35 MPa, fy=400 MPa. Trial T-section: overall depth h=600 mm, web bw=300 mm, flange (slab) thickness hf=150 mm, effective flange width bE=1500 mm (governed by span/4=1.5 m, the smallest of the CSA A23.3 Cl. 10.4 limits with an assumed 2.4 m beam spacing); effective depth d=535 mm.

Find. (a) Factored design moments/shears including self-weight; (b) flexural reinforcement, positive and negative; (c) shear reinforcement.

100 kNAB300 kNC1 m3 m3 m
Figure B1: overhang T-beam, roller at B, pin at C; 100 kN at tip A, 300 kN at midspan of BC.

Approach. Compute the self-weight UDL from the trial T-section, superpose it on the two point loads to get the reactions and the V/M envelope, then design the midspan (T-beam, flange in compression) and support (rectangular web, flange in tension) sections separately, and the stirrups at the critical shear section.

  1. (a) Self-weight and reactions. Trial section area $$A=1500(150)+300(450)=360\,000\text{ mm}^2\Rightarrow w_{self}=0.36(24)=\boxed{8.64\text{ kN/m}}$$ over the full 7 m length. Solving equilibrium with the two point loads and the UDL: $$R_B=\boxed{302.0\text{ kN}},\qquad R_C=\boxed{158.5\text{ kN}}\ \text{(unfactored)}$$ Integrating V gives a hogging peak $$M(B)=-100(1)-8.64(1)^2/2=\boxed{-104.3\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$$, a sagging peak at the 300 kN load point (x=4 m from A) of $$M=\boxed{+436.7\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$$, and maximum shear just right of B, $$V_{max}=\boxed{193.3\text{ kN}}$$. Factoring by 1.5: $$M_f^+=655\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m},\quad M_f^-=156\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m},\quad V_f=290\text{ kN}$$
  2. (b) Positive (midspan) steel – T-beam action. With $$\alpha_1=0.85-0.0015f_c'=0.7975$$ and compression in the bE=1500 mm flange: $$M_r=\phi_sA_sf_y\left(d-\frac{A_sf_y}{2\alpha_1f_c'b_E}\right)=M_f^+\ \Rightarrow\ A_s=\boxed{3730\text{ mm}^2}$$ Select 6–30M (4200 mm², two per web-width row): stress-block depth $$a=A_sf_y/(\alpha_1f_c'b_E)=40.1\text{ mm} < h_f=150\text{ mm}\ \checkmark$$ (true T-behaviour confirmed) and $$M_r=\boxed{735\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} \ge 655\ \checkmark$$
  3. Negative (support) steel – rectangular web. At B the flange is in tension, so only the bw=300 mm web resists compression: $$M_r=\phi_sA_sf_y\left(d-\frac{A_sf_y}{2\alpha_1f_c'b_w}\right)=M_f^-\ \Rightarrow\ A_s=\boxed{896\text{ mm}^2}$$ Select 2–25M top bars (1000 mm²) extending from A across B into the span a full development length: $$a=47.8\text{ mm},\qquad M_r=\boxed{174\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}} \ge 156\ \checkmark$$ Both exceed $$A_{s,min}=0.2\sqrt{f_c'}/f_y\, b_wh=532\text{ mm}^2$$.
  4. (c) Shear design. $$d_v=\max(0.9d,0.72h)=481.5\text{ mm}$$ With the simplified method (β=0.18, λ=1.0): $$V_c=\beta\lambda\phi_c\sqrt{f_c'}\,b_wd_v=\boxed{100\text{ kN}}$$ Required steel contribution: $$V_s\ge(V_f-V_c)/\phi_s=224\text{ kN}$$ Using 2-legged 10M stirrups (Av=200 mm²) at θ=35°: $$s=\frac{\phi_sA_vf_yd_v\cot\theta}{V_s}=\boxed{209\text{ mm}}\Rightarrow \text{use 10M @ 200 mm c/c}$$ near both supports, opening to a nominal 300 mm spacing beyond the point loads where Vf drops.
QuantityValue
wself8.64 kN/m
RB, RC (unfactored)302.0 kN, 158.5 kN
Mf+, Mf−, Vf655 kN·m, 156 kN·m, 290 kN
Positive steel (midspan)6–30M (Mr=735 kN·m)
Negative steel (at B)2–25M (Mr=174 kN·m)
Stirrups10M, 2-leg @ 200 mm c/c near supports