Question 6 of 6: n-Heptane / n-Octane Vapour–Liquid Equilibrium from Raoult’s Law
Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)
Notes on this paper
Reference texts: Incropera, DeWitt, Bergman & Lavine, Fundamentals of Heat and Mass Transfer (Wiley) — variable-conductivity conduction, resistance networks, convection correlations; Coulson & Richardson, Chemical Engineering Vol. 1 (Butterworth-Heinemann) — double-pipe exchanger sizing, evaporator heat load, diffusion through stagnant films; Geankoplis, Transport Processes and Separation Process Principles (4th ed., Prentice Hall) — molecular-diffusion flux relations and two-film interphase transfer; Treybal, Mass-Transfer Operations (3rd ed., McGraw-Hill) — gas absorption. Property data from Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook (9th ed.).
Exam format: six problems worth 25 points each — three in Part A (Heat Transfer) and three in Part B (Mass Transfer, printed as Problems 1–3 of Part B and numbered Questions 4–6 here). At least two problems from each part must be attempted and only the first two from each section are marked. Open-book, three-hour paper. All six problems are solved here for completeness.
Paper note
This is the 16-CHEM-A3 Heat and Mass Transfer paper of May 2019. The printed paper is five pages (cover notes, Part A Problems 1–3, Part B Problems 1–3), followed by two sheets of graph paper and a periodic table.
Part A — Heat Transfer
Question 6: n-Heptane / n-Octane Vapour–Liquid Equilibrium from Raoult’s Law (25 points)
Given. Binary n-heptane ($A$, the more volatile component, normal boiling point 98.4 °C) and n-octane ($B$, normal boiling point 125.6 °C) at total pressure $P=101.325$ kPa. The table gives the pure-component vapour pressures $P_A^{\text{sat}}$, $P_B^{\text{sat}}$ at six temperatures spanning the two boiling points. Ideal liquid (Raoult) and ideal vapour (Dalton).
Find. The equilibrium $y$–$x$ relation (tabulated points and a closed-form relation) and the $x$–$y$ equilibrium diagram.
Approach. At each tabulated temperature the liquid is at its bubble point under $P$. Raoult plus Dalton gives $x_A$ from the pressure balance and $y_A$ from the partial-pressure ratio. The relative volatility $\alpha=P_A^{\text{sat}}/P_B^{\text{sat}}$ is nearly constant for this near-ideal paraffin pair, so an averaged $\alpha$ yields a single analytic equilibrium curve for plotting and stage calculations.
Raoult–Dalton relations. Ideal liquid: $p_A=x_AP_A^{\text{sat}}$, $p_B=(1-x_A)P_B^{\text{sat}}$. Ideal vapour: $y_A=p_A/P$. Because the partial pressures sum to $P$,$$x_A=\frac{P-P_B^{\text{sat}}}{P_A^{\text{sat}}-P_B^{\text{sat}}},\qquad y_A=\frac{x_AP_A^{\text{sat}}}{P}.$$
Worked point, 110 °C.$$x_A=\frac{101.325-64.528}{139.988-64.528}=\frac{36.797}{75.460}=0.488,\qquad y_A=\frac{0.488(139.988)}{101.325}=0.674,\qquad \alpha=\frac{139.988}{64.528}=2.17.$$
All tabulated points. Repeating at each temperature:
$T$ (°C)
$x_A$
$y_A$
$\alpha=P_A^{\text{sat}}/P_B^{\text{sat}}$
98.4
1.000
1.000
2.282
105
0.656
0.811
2.254
110
0.488
0.674
2.169
115
0.311
0.492
2.139
120
0.157
0.279
2.077
125.6
0.000
0.000
2.026
The end rows check the data: at 98.4 °C $P_A^{\text{sat}}=P$ gives pure heptane ($x=y=1$), and at 125.6 °C $P_B^{\text{sat}}=P$ gives pure octane.
Equilibrium relation. Since $y_A/x_A=\alpha\,(1-y_A)/(1-x_A)$, the ideal-system relation is$$y=\frac{\alpha x}{1+(\alpha-1)x}.$$$\alpha$ falls only from 2.28 to 2.03 across the column, so its geometric mean over the six temperatures, $\alpha_{\text{avg}}=2.16$, represents the system:$$\boxed{\,y=\frac{2.16\,x}{1+1.16\,x}\,}$$Check at $x=0.488$: $y=2.16(0.488)/[1+1.16(0.488)]=0.672$, against 0.674 from Raoult. The largest deviation from the tabulated points is 0.008 in $y$, at 120 °C.
Equilibrium diagram. Plot $y$ against $x$ on 0–1 axes with the $45^\circ$ line $y=x$ (Figure 6). The six Raoult points lie on the smooth constant-$\alpha$ curve, which bows well above the diagonal. That gap is what makes heptane/octane separable by distillation; a larger $\alpha$ would open it further and need fewer stages.
Figure 6 — $x$–$y$ equilibrium diagram for n-heptane / n-octane at 101.325 kPa. Red points are computed from the tabulated vapour pressures by Raoult’s and Dalton’s laws; the blue curve is $y=2.16x/(1+1.16x)$; the dashed line is $y=x$.