Question 2 of 5: Combining Two Iron-Oxide Equilibria to get K and ΔG° for the Water–Gas-Shift Reaction
Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)
Notes on this paper
National Exams — 12-Mtl-A1, Materials Thermodynamics. Three-hour, closed-book
exam; one double-sided aid sheet and an approved (Casio or Sharp) calculator permitted.
The cover page states “All FIVE (5) questions need to be answered” — there is no
choice among Questions 1–4, and Question 5 offers a straight OR
between two alternative problems of equal weight (15%); both are solved below for
completeness. Marks: Q1 25%, Q2 15%, Q3 20%, Q4 25%, Q5 15%.
Reference texts: Gaskell, D. R., Introduction to
the Thermodynamics of Materials (2nd–5th ed.) — Ch. 6 (Kirchhoff’s
law and the temperature dependence of ΔH° and ΔS°), Ch. 9 (partial and
integral molar excess free energies, Gibbs–Duhem integration, chemical-equilibrium
constants), and Ch. 12–13 (oxide/carbide stability, Ellingham-type ΔG°(T)
expressions for extractive metallurgy).
Question 2: Combining Two Iron-Oxide Equilibria to get K and ΔG° for the Water–Gas-Shift Reaction (15%)
Given. K1, K2 at 600, 800, 1000 °C from the table above.
Find. K and ΔG° for CO + H2O ↔ CO2 + H2 at the same three temperatures.
Approach. Combine the two given equilibria by Hess’s law: adding
Reaction 1 (forward) to Reaction 2 (reversed) cancels FeO(s) and Fe(s) and gives
exactly the target reaction, so Ktarget = K1/K2, then ΔG° = −RT ln K.
Combine the two equilibria. Reaction 1 forward + Reaction 2
reversed: [FeO+CO→Fe+CO2] + [Fe+H2O→FeO+H2] =
CO+H2O→CO2+H2, the target reaction. Reversing
Reaction 2 inverts its equilibrium constant, so
$$K_{target}=K_1\times\frac{1}{K_2}=\frac{K_1}{K_2}$$
T = 1000°C (1273 K).
$$K_{target}=\frac{0.396}{0.668}=0.593\qquad \Delta G^{\circ}=-(8.314)(1273)\ln(0.593)$$
$$\boxed{\Delta G^{\circ}=+5534\text{ J}=+5.53\text{ kJ}}$$
Note the sign change between 800°C and 1000°C: the water–gas-shift reaction
switches from mildly product-favoured to mildly reactant-favoured as K1 falls
faster than K2 rises with temperature.