NivaarExam PrepOfficial exam papers ↗

16-Civ-A1 Elementary Structural Analysis · December 2015

Question 2 of 8: Reactions, shear- and bending-moment diagrams

Nivaar worked solution (AI-drafted; not reviewed by a licensed engineer)

Notes on this paper

Reference texts: R.C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis (10th ed., Pearson) — determinacy, method of joints/sections, virtual-work deflections, moment distribution / slope–deflection, influence lines; A. Kassimali, Structural Analysis (6th ed., Cengage) — internal hinges, compound (Gerber) beams and three-hinged frames. Sign convention: sagging bending moment positive, upward reactions positive, member tension positive (T) / compression negative (C).

The paper requires Q1–Q4 in full plus two of Q5/Q6/Q7/Q8. For completeness all eight questions are worked here.

Question 2: Reactions, shear- and bending-moment diagrams (18 marks)

Question text not reproduced: the examination questions are © Engineers and Geoscientists BC. Open the official past paper (linked at the top of this page) to read the question, then follow the worked solution below.

2(a) — compound beam with an internal hinge

Given.

Pin A at $x=0$; roller B at $x=12$ m; roller C at $x=21$ mInternal hinge H at $x=9$ m
UDL $w=6$ kN/m over $0\le x\le12$ mPoint loads $18$ kN ↓ at $x=15$ and $x=18$ m

Find. Reactions and the SFD / BMD with extreme ordinates.

6 kN/m hinge (9 m) 18 kN 18 kN ABC
2(a): pin–roller–roller compound beam, one internal hinge at 9 m.

Approach. Cut at the hinge (moment there is zero); solve the left rigid link, carry the hinge shear into the right link, then finish by statics.

  1. Left link A–H ($0\le x\le9$, carries $6\times9=54$ kN at $x=4.5$). Take moments about the hinge: $R_A(9)=54(4.5)\Rightarrow R_A=\dfrac{243}{9}=\boxed{27\text{ kN}\uparrow}$. Hinge shear $V_H=54-27=27$ kN.
  2. Right link H–C carries the $27$ kN transferred down at H ($x=9$), the remaining UDL $6\times3=18$ kN at $x=10.5$, and $18{+}18$ kN at $x=15,18$. Moments about B ($x=12$): $R_C(9)=27(3)+18(1.5)-18(3)-18(6)$, i.e. $9R_C=54\Rightarrow R_C=\boxed{6\text{ kN}\uparrow}$.
  3. Vertical equilibrium. $R_A+R_B+R_C=6(12)+18+18=108\Rightarrow R_B=108-27-6=\boxed{75\text{ kN}\uparrow}$. Horizontal: $H_A=0$.
  4. Shear. $V=+27$ at A, falling under the UDL to $-27$ at the hinge and $-45$ just left of B; jump $+75$ to $+30$; constant to $x=15$, drop to $+12$, then $-6$ after $x=18$, closing at C. $\;V_{\max}=+30,\;V_{\min}=-45$ kN.
  5. Moment. Sagging peak where $V=0$ at $x=4.5$: $M=27(4.5)-3(4.5)^2=\boxed{+60.75\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$; zero at the hinge; hogging minimum over B, $M_B=6(9)-18(3)-18(6)=\boxed{-108\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$; back to zero at C.
SFD (kN) +27−45+30+12−6 BMD (kN·m) +60.75 (sag)−108 (hog, over B)
2(a): SFD and BMD. Sagging positive; hogging −108 kN·m over support B is the governing (minimum) ordinate.
QuantityValue
$R_A,\,R_B,\,R_C$27, 75, 6 kN (all ↑)
$V_{\max},\,V_{\min}$+30 kN, −45 kN
$M_{\max}$ (sag)+60.75 kN·m at $x=4.5$ m
$M_{\min}$ (hog)−108 kN·m over B

2(b) — rigid Γ-bent (beam + hanging leg)

Given. Horizontal beam 0–9 m at eaves level, roller at the left end (vertical reaction), a 3 m leg dropping from the right end to a pin base; $w=6$ kN/m down on the beam; a $12$ kN horizontal force ($\rightarrow$) at the beam–column knee.

Find. Reactions, SFD/BMD of both members.

6 kN/m 12 kN ABJ
2(b): roller at A, pin at base B, 12 kN horizontal at knee J.

Approach. Only the base pin resists horizontal load; take global equilibrium.

  1. Horizontal. $H_B+12=0\Rightarrow H_B=\boxed{12\text{ kN}\leftarrow}$.
  2. Moments about B $(9,0)$: roller $R_A$ (at $x=0$, up), UDL $54$ kN at $x=4.5$, and the $12$ kN at height $3$ m: $-9R_A+54(4.5)-12(3)=0\Rightarrow R_A=\dfrac{207}{9}=\boxed{23\text{ kN}\uparrow}$.
  3. Vertical. $V_B=54-23=\boxed{31\text{ kN}\uparrow}$.
  4. Beam. $V(x)=23-6x$ ⇒ zero at $x=3.83$ m, giving $M_{\max}=23(3.83)-3(3.83)^2=\boxed{+44.1\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$ (sag); at the knee $M_J=23(9)-3(9)^2=-36$ kN·m (hog).
  5. Leg. Constant shear $12$ kN; moment $0$ at the pin base, rising linearly to $12(3)=\boxed{36\text{ kN}\cdot\text{m}}$ at the knee — equal and opposite to the beam-end moment, so the rigid joint balances ($\sum M_J=0$).
QuantityValue
$R_A$ (roller)23 kN ↑
$V_B,\,H_B$ (base pin)31 kN ↑, 12 kN ←
Beam $M_{\max}$ / knee $M$+44.1 (sag, at 3.83 m) / −36 (hog) kN·m
Leg $M$0 at base → 36 kN·m at knee

2(c) — bent with an inclined roller

Check (reconstructed figure). The faint page-3 drawing is read as: pin at A$(0,0)$; vertical left column 7.2 m to B$(0,7.2)$; horizontal top beam B→C carrying $6$ kN/m over a 9.6 m span, C$(9.6,7.2)$; a roller on a 3:4 incline at C giving a reaction perpendicular to that surface. The method below is exact for this model; if the roller sits at a different node the numbers scale accordingly.

Given. $w=6$ kN/m over 9.6 m; pin A; inclined roller (normal $\mathbf n=(-\tfrac35,\tfrac45)$) at C.

Find. Reactions.

  1. Resultant load. $W=6(9.6)=57.6$ kN ↓ at $x=4.8$ m.
  2. Moments about A with roller force $R\mathbf n$ at C: $x_C(\tfrac45R)-y_C(-\tfrac35R)=W(4.8)$, i.e. $(9.6)(0.8R)+(7.2)(0.6R)=276.48\Rightarrow 12.0R=276.48\Rightarrow R=\boxed{23.0\text{ kN}}$.
  3. Equilibrium. $A_x=-R n_x=+13.8$ kN, $A_y=W-Rn_y=57.6-18.4=\boxed{39.2\text{ kN}\uparrow}$, $A_x=\boxed{13.8\text{ kN}\rightarrow}$.
  4. Beam moment. The 9.6 m span under $6$ kN/m develops a free sagging moment up to $wL^2/8=6(9.6)^2/8=69.1$ kN·m, superposed on the axial thrust delivered by the inclined reaction.
QuantityValue (adopted model)
Inclined-roller reaction $R$23.0 kN (⊥ to 3:4 face)
Pin A$A_x=13.8$ kN →, $A_y=39.2$ kN ↑
Beam free moment $wL^2/8$69.1 kN·m (sag)